Our Reserve Cheese

Old World Cheddar

Sweet and savory with a buttery finish. Sharp notes highlight the robust flavor of this white cheddar.

Sartori Shop
Old World Cheddar


Best Cheddar Cheese

PEOPLE Food Awards 2022

First Place

2023 Wisconsin State Fair

Third Place

2019 Wisconsin State Fair

Old World Cheddar Brick

Available Sizes

Taste Notes

Want sharp flavor? You got it. Savory meets buttery with notes of fruit. There’s nothing quite like it.

Our Italian cheddars bring a unique taste profile and excitement to every occasion.

Old World Cheddar Spider Graph

One-of-a-kind cheddar.

Inspired by our 80-year cheesemaking heritage, our Master Cheesemakers used Italian-inspired cultures to create this unique flavor experience.

Lots of ways to spice up Old World Cheddar

Pairing Guide

Old World Cheddar delivers a unique flavor with sweet & savory notes and finishes with a buttery touch. Delightful sharpness highlights and brightens this robust, flavorful white cheddar.

Learn more

Enjoy with a glass of...

Old World Cheddar with drink pairings




Stout Beer

Nibble on...

Old World Cheddar with food pairings


Almonds, Baguette


Apples, Cherry Preserves

Featured Recipe

Cheddar Biscuits with Old World Cheddar

Not to knock normal biscuits... but once you go Cheddar, you never go back.

Cheddar Biscuits with Old World Cheddar